Hi zach,

I think you are looking for a different workflow action in step 2:

Make changes to thing: (The source)
List of wisdoms add: Result of step 1.

(Your current workflow is just changing the list but not adding the thing you created to the sources list of wisdoms)

To be able to access the right source, I have this step inside a group with that source.

Here are some screens from a workflow where someone adds a comment to a post, and everyone associated gets a notification. (So the post is like your source and I was referring to step 3 of that workflow)
Hope this helps and is what you wanted.